#183: How to Get Dream Guests on Your Podcast - Even With a Small Audience Video 24 min

Do you need a massive audience before you can invite great guests onto your podcast? Not necessarily. A small show can open the door to meaningful conversations and business relationships when you start with the right strategy.

In this episode, we interview Robert Plank, founder of DFY Podcast and host of Marketer of the Day. Robert has hosted more than 1,500 podcast interviews and helped over 65 podcasters launch and grow their shows.

Robert shares how creators can find guests in their existing network, prepare for interviews that bring out valuable stories, and build relationships that continue long after the recording ends.

We also discuss how to repurpose and promote episodes, discover potential guests through other podcasts and LinkedIn, and use consistent daily action to make progress on the work that matters.

You’ll learn:

  • How to find relevant podcast guests even when your audience is small
  • How to prepare guests and create a comfortable, productive interview
  • How to follow up, repurpose episodes, and turn conversations into lasting relationships

Learn more about Robert Plank and DFY Podcast: https://dfypodcast.com/



Transcript

Bryan McAnulty [00:00]:

It's happened to me too. I invite a guest to my podcast and I never hear back. Today's guest, Robert Plank, has a solution for securing high-profile guests to appear on your podcast.

Robert Plank [00:09]:

If you really want to stand out as a real quality podcast host, follow up with your guests, especially with ways that they can promote the show, because it benefits both of you. And so few podcasters do it: following up with the guests.

Bryan McAnulty [00:22]:

Robert has hosted more than 1,500 interviews on his daily show, Marketer of the Day, and has helped over 65 podcasters launch and grow their shows. But he doesn't treat podcasting just as another content channel. He sees it as one of the smartest ways to build trust, create relationships, and open the door to new clients, referrals, and partnerships. But here's the best part: according to Robert, you do not need a massive audience to bring amazing guests onto your show. You just need the right strategy, the right invitation, and a clear reason for people to say yes.

Robert Plank [00:48]:

If you're pursuing big podcast guests, maybe you need to reconsider your goals. Grow your circle wherever you're at. If you try to shoot for these huge names, of course they don't want to be on your show that only gets five downloads, because, like, why would they? That's not a good match.

Bryan McAnulty [01:03]:

So today we're interviewing Robert Plank about how to get dream guests on your podcast, even if your audience is still small, and how to turn those conversations into real business opportunities. Welcome to The Creator's Adventure, where we interview creators from around the world, hearing their stories about growing a business. Hey everyone, I'm Bryan McAnulty, the founder of Heights Platform. Let's get into it.

Bryan McAnulty [01:26]:

Hey Robert, welcome to the show.

Robert Plank [01:28]:

Happy to be here. How are you?

Bryan McAnulty [01:30]:

I'm doing well. Yeah, we just got to talk recently. I was on your show, your podcast as well.

Robert Plank:

Yes.

Bryan McAnulty:

So everybody, go ahead and check that out: Marketer of the Day. But yeah, my first question for you is, what would you say is the biggest thing either you did or you are doing that has helped you to achieve the freedom to do what you enjoy?

Robert Plank [01:45]:

Putting in the reps, talking to people every day. And that means podcasting, that means sales calls, that means hopping on LinkedIn and getting people warmed up. There's all kinds of sayings throughout history of, like, if you just do a little bit every day, then look at what it will add up to. And I feel like I've, the past few years especially, built up the muscle, right? It's like anything new is awkward. And so if you're like, “Oh, well, I can't make a website. I can't build a list. I can't follow up with prospects or customers,” well, if you're not doing it regularly, then you are out of shape.

And I think that whatever recurring tasks you have to do, especially involving people, it's worth just getting into some kind of daily habit. That way you get stronger and that way it becomes effortless. So I think what I do best, or the secret to my success, is persistence and doing something on a repeat basis every day.

Bryan McAnulty [02:39]:

Yeah, I think that's great advice. I completely agree with it. For you at the beginning, was that something that you felt came easy or was it difficult? Did you want to do these things or did you not want to do them?

Robert Plank [02:48]:

Probably didn't want to do them. I mean, as adults, you know, like 70% of what we do, we don't want to do, right? And it's like, is it really that much fun to clear out your inbox or to do those follow-ups? But we all have this pesky addiction to eating food and drinking water and breathing air and clothing ourselves. So there's some things that we have to do. And it's like, you need to apply discipline, not motivation.

And I think a real rut that's so tempting to get stuck in is waiting until you're excited to do something. And that just comes and goes, right? Sometimes it's a roll of the dice if you wake up happy or wake up just sort of okay. There's a lot of things where, if you want to have a business, you need to be consistent. You need to deliver for your customers.

So sometimes you don't want to do some things, and sometimes you do things and maybe five minutes in or halfway through, you're like, “Hey, this isn't so bad. This is kind of interesting and exciting, customizing my YouTube page or editing videos.” So there's a lot of tasks where if you just go ahead and do it or start on it, you'll wonder why you procrastinated so much anyway.

Bryan McAnulty [03:52]:

Yeah. And also, there's many things in life, I think, that even if it's something that you think you might enjoy doing, when you start, it's not enjoyable because of how bad you are or whatever. But as you get better at the thing, then sometimes it's enjoyable to be good at a thing and see what you can accomplish from that.

Robert Plank [04:09]:

Oh yeah. You think about the messy middle. I'm sure you were in some kind of sports at some point as a kid, and I was in Little League. If you're just goofing around and throwing a baseball around, I guess it's sort of fun. And then if you have to learn the rules and you have to strike out at bat or you miss the ball or whatever, you get tagged out, that's not fun. But then those few times when you break through and there's the structure and the rules and then you succeed anyway, it's like fun times 10. It's like fun plus fulfillment.

There are a lot of parallels to that. You could be just goofing around. It could be a hobby. Okay, you're not really trying. You're not really putting in an effort. And then there's effort plus the satisfaction at the end, at the breakthrough moment of that. Boy, is that really something.

Bryan McAnulty [04:51]:

Yeah, I agree. And I thought of sports and everything as the first thing that came to my mind as well. For me, I was thinking about skateboarding. You try to do a jump or some kind of trick and the thing just hits you in the shin over and over. It's not fun at all. And then when you learn to do it, all of a sudden it's 10 times more fun than maybe you thought it would be, even.

Robert Plank [05:08]:

Yeah, but the only downside is that there is frustration mixed in there. But the point of life is not to be happy 100% of the time, right? The point of life is not for things to be 100% easy. You do have to have some work mixed in there.

Bryan McAnulty [05:23]:

So I want to talk with you about podcasting. I think a lot of creators assume that they need a big audience before they can invite impressive guests. Why would you say that that belief might be wrong?

Robert Plank [05:33]:

Well, I love the quotation from, I think, John D. Rockefeller that says, “I'd rather have 100 people helping me 1% than one person helping me 100%.” And I think that if you're pursuing big podcast guests, maybe you need to reconsider your goals, right? I mean, what's the point of your podcast? Well, the point of your podcast is to grow your circle wherever you're at. So if you try to shoot for these huge names, of course they don't want to be on your show that only gets five downloads, because, like, why would they? That's not a good match.

But if you can get your best customers and your vendors and the people that are already in your orbit and strengthen those relationships, and then get that growing, then you can grow your circle in that way. I think the point of your podcast is to get more attention on what you do in a way that also helps other people at the same time. So if your circle's here and you're trying to get someone way out there who's not even anywhere close to your orbit, not in your niche, your industry, not related to your company or your brand, then it's not even a goal.

So I think that at first your podcast should be there to grow and preserve and maybe even document the relationships that you have, right? Like, you have your membership platform and you've interviewed people that use it on your podcast. And so it's a fun way of selling without selling, right? Because you're not just walking through, “Oh, here's the steps on creating your online course.” You're saying, “Hey, here's this person. They had a dream or they were stuck in some way, and they used my software to get where they need to go, and there's a fun story here.” And there's this other person with a similar but different journey, where they used my platform as well. So you start with the people that are near you and you don't shoot for those long shots. And so at first, the views and all that, it doesn't matter because that's not what the goal is currently.

Bryan McAnulty [07:27]:

Real quick, Bryan here. You know me as the host for this podcast, but what you might not know is I'm also the founder of Heights Platform. It's an all-in-one platform that over 10,000 creators have used to build their online courses, communities, and digital product businesses. We recently added some awesome updates to Heights AI to help you turn your idea into a viable business. Heights AI can build entire product offers, review your content, and even coach you on how to grow. You can try it for free for 30 days. Link's in the description. Now back to the podcast.

Bryan McAnulty [07:56]:

Yeah, that's great advice, and definitely I would agree. The second-order value that I'm getting from this is not because one particular person that I dreamed I could talk to, I got to talk with them. It's that I got to make all these connections with all these people like yourself. And I think people who are maybe doing a podcast, especially if it's an interview-related show, they are missing out on maybe even considering that benefit. They think, “Oh, what am I going to do that's going to get me views?” And it's great that a podcast can help to market or grow your business, right? But then you get to also make these connections with the guests.

Robert Plank [08:24]:

Oh yeah. Podcasting is a great filter. There's such randomness, like how you and I met, but there's also some people that you're not really sure how the relationship will proceed, right? There might be someone who's a client or potential client, or maybe someone talking to you on LinkedIn, and you see if they'll be on your show. And I think those that step up, they're kind of the next level beyond. And so the people that you're not really sure if they're serious business people or if there's good chemistry with you or if it'll lead to something, get them on your podcast. And boy, that's a real throw a person in the fire and see if they can really deliver.

Bryan McAnulty [08:59]:

Yeah, I agree. So for the creator out there who's just starting a podcast, let's say they realize, “Okay, I don't have to go for the biggest name that I can imagine to be the guest of my show right away.” What will still help them get a guest to say yes when their show is still small?

Robert Plank [09:12]:

Okay, so I guess there's probably a few levels to this, right? Because if you're starting off and if you don't have any content, you need to record something. So don't even let a guest hold you back, right? Record your first episode or your first couple episodes yourself. Talk about a few people that you've helped, talk about your origin story.

And then if you're on that next level and you're like, “Well, who should I invite to be on my podcast?” see who's closest around you. Do you have a good mentor or a few really good customers and clients? And don't even go into it with a lot of expectations. Because you were on my show, now I'm on your show, and you know that the podcast doesn't really have that much of an agenda, right? The focus is, you have this guest, you want to make them look good, you want to get some interesting stories from them. So if you can get a good story about a mentor, a past colleague, or a good client or customer, I think those are some good buckets to start with.

Bryan McAnulty [10:08]:

Yeah, that's good advice. What do you say about the idea of either guests—let's say that you're trying to either have a guest on your show or you're trying to go on their show. What do you think about the type of guest who will say, “I want you to pay me to have me be on your show,” or vice versa, if you want to go on their show, “Oh, I want you to pay me for it”?

Robert Plank [10:25]:

Well, there's more fish in the sea, right? So I have had people pay to be on my show, and my justification for that is if there's someone where I don't know them, a booking agency approaches me and they're a good fit, but it's like, I still don't know them. I'll charge a little fee and then I'll put that back into advertising. I'll run some YouTube ads on the episode and things like that.

But if someone says, “Well, you should pay me to be on your show,” I mean, it is tempting. I think I heard Michael Gerber, the E-Myth author, I think he charges 1,500 bucks. So it's like, well, to get that name connection, that's tempting for me. I also haven't paid it. I guess it's on a case-by-case basis. If it's a household name-ish, like a Michael Gerber, it depends on what the price is. But it's not a thing that you really need to do regularly because there's podcasts that you could be on all day long and podcast guests that would be on your show all day long.

And so I think that, you know, I know some people are really against any kind of money changing hands. And I've paid a couple times to be on some shows just to test it afterwards. But it's not a thing that you need to let hold you back or even consider thinking about early on.

Bryan McAnulty [11:39]:

Great. So you've done more than 1,500 interviews now. What have you learned about making guests open up or share the more valuable stories and insights?

Robert Plank [11:48]:

Well, I think it's important to be relaxed, like, know what you're doing. And I think the biggest positive the past couple of years is I have a little bit of an unofficial script that I say before the show. I think you might have heard. I do it every time without thinking. I think I might have written it down at some point, but I don't have it in front of me. So I just lay out the agenda.

Because I think that it's so weird to explain it this way, but it's almost like a guy and a girl on a date, right? It's like right now you're the man and I'm the woman, and then when you were on my show, it was flipped. I'm sorry if it sounds sexist, but it's like if you're a man, right, and there's a hot girl you're out to dinner with, you don't want to be talking her ear off. You want to ask interesting questions of her, but by you being the question asker, you're kind of the leader, right? You're kind of in control, but you're not in full control, right? It's kind of a dance between two people.

And so you keep that in mind, that you're just there to be curious, ask questions. You have a few things that are planned, but if there's an interesting thread to follow, then it's like, “Ooh, well, tell me more about that.” And that's, I think, when the unexpectedness comes, when you're both there improvising in the moment and you follow the thread.

But the short answer there is I lay out the quick agenda ahead of time. Say there's Bryan McAnulty there and we're about to record. I say, “Hey, here's the name of the show, here's who the audience is, and my plan is I'll read some of the bio I have in front of me, toss it to you to fill in the gaps, and then I'm always looking for struggle stories, success stories. And then near the end of our 20-minute interview, I'll be asking you about the missing question that I should be asking you, I just don't know to ask you. Then we'll drop some links, next steps, and afterwards I'll ask about a fun or interesting quote or lesson that has served you.”

So I say all those things, and I feel it just helps relax us both more because you know what's coming. And it opens us up to say, “Okay, well, now we have our road map laid out,” right? We're driving from Los Angeles to New York City, and now we don't have to worry about this or that turn. And if we see something fun on the side of the road, then we can do that. But because we have a loose plan, now we don't have to worry so much.

Bryan McAnulty [14:00]:

Yeah, that's great advice. I think for somebody starting out, it's really helpful to hear that, especially because there's definitely cases, especially more so early on, where I've had somebody on and then I thought we were going from Los Angeles to New York City and suddenly they're going to Chicago or something, right? So it helps to align on that and basically say, this is roughly where we're expecting to be. And that way there's no surprises on either end and you're both more comfortable, and you can hopefully share those interesting ideas with each other.

Robert Plank [14:26]:

Yeah, you fulfill your roles properly.

Bryan McAnulty [14:29]:

Yeah. How would you say a podcast host can turn that one interview into a stronger relationship after the recording ends?

Robert Plank [14:38]:

Follow up in whatever way makes sense. I know some guys that are so skilled—I've been on shows where they sold me at the end. They scheduled a sales call afterwards. So that's kind of the obvious direct way. But then the hot topic with podcasting is repurposing, right? So instead of just having the audio of the podcast, you put it on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and you're done, you use it in all sorts of different ways, right? You take the video, put it on YouTube, cut up the reels, put it on TikTok, take the best quotes, make graphics, put it on Instagram, take the transcript and turn it into blog posts or LinkedIn posts.

So there's repurposing. And then the fun of the repurposing and the posting is tagging, right? I mean, we've all heard this, right? You record something and you turn it into all these posts for different platforms. And I think if you do just that, it's tough to get a following, tough to get traffic. But then if you have guests, well, all these platforms—TikTok, Instagram, LinkedIn, Facebook, et cetera—if they're a decent guest, they're on all of these. So you go and find them on that platform, and they probably have at least a few thousand followers because they are serious enough about their business to get on shows. So you tag them on all these different platforms, and now you're tapping into their audience as well.

And some podcasters get there, but a lot of them stop there. And what I do is I make an effort to follow up with all my guests every quarter, every 90 days. And you have to get creative and think of reasons to follow up, right? You can't just say, “Buy my stuff, buy my stuff.” And so what I have ended up doing is, I've got these almost 1,600 episodes now. I started the interview format around episode 100, and for every guest I create a shared Google folder. And this folder has all these things we talked about, right? Images, reels, swipe files, things like that.

And then I go and share them with every single guest and I follow up and I say, “Hey, here's how to use it.” And I follow up later saying, “Hey, can you grab the image and put it on your Instagram? Or can you grab the video and put it on your TikTok?” And I just follow up with different ways to get them to promote. And then depending on where I am in my sequence, sometimes I'll say, “Well, let's schedule another call to catch up.” And if it's been many years, “Well, let's schedule another call to have you back on the show.”

So I think that most podcast hosts, they just post the podcast audio. That's it. Some podcast hosts then do the repurposing and the tagging. And if you really want to stand out as a real quality podcast host, follow up with your guests, especially with ways that they can promote the show, because it benefits both of you. And so few podcasters do it: following up with the guests.

Bryan McAnulty [17:21]:

Yeah, that's a great point. What would you say, if somebody wants to leverage podcasting as a relationship-building strategy, what should they do in their first 30 days?

Robert Plank [17:29]:

I would get on LinkedIn and I would listen to other shows because it's a lot of fun. You and I were talking about earlier, we know some of the same people, right? And so you grow this audience and you want to be intentional about the guests that you're getting. Just figure out who will help you get there. And I think that focusing on your customers is probably the most fun because then you can see who are the ones that are coachable and good public speakers.

And then you can, depending on your AI skills, have a lot of fun with the keyword research and especially the iterative loop. That's what excites me these days because, say you have a few podcast episodes and then you get them all transcribed, and then you feed those transcripts into AI and you say, “Well, what are the intent keywords? What are the customer keywords? How would you group or cluster these guests that we've had or the topics?”

And then LinkedIn is so amazing because you can search anyone based on keyword. It's just so deep because the keyword search on LinkedIn covers if someone has certain keywords in a job title or bio, but also if they posted about something. And so, if you were growing your business about membership sites and paywalls and continuity programs, and you went in and you searched, maybe you find some up-and-coming payment processor, and they would be a good, kind of off-the-beaten-path guest to have on. And just that iterative loop: you feed the keywords into AI and use that, then you as a human judge that and use that to go and find more people. It's a lot of fun.

And for such a long time, I was doing what I would call podcast stalking. And so if I had a really good guest, like Mr. Bryan McAnulty, I could go and find other shows that you were on, and then go through those guests and contact those guests. And a lot of them were, even when I had such a small show, so eager to be on just because they were habitual podcast guests. And it's like, just having that one good guest, you find out other lookalikes of them. It can just be a lot of fun just to be on the hunt for those people.

Bryan McAnulty [19:36]:

Yeah, that's a great point. I feel like my team's got to look into your guest list on your podcast a little bit. As you mentioned, we have had some similar guests on and some connections with that before we had known each other. It's neat how you can unlock and get yourself into these spaces and build these relationships with these other people through that process of discovery.

Robert Plank [19:53]:

Oh yeah. It's a good foot in the door, and we've all been in those awkward networking meetings where you exchange business cards, you're not really sure what you're supposed to talk about. But if you talk to someone and you schedule just a five- or ten-minute pre-call, and you say, “Hey, I'd like to have you on my show,” then you have a goal even though you don't know each other yet. And you're not just wasting each other's time, and you're not going out on a limb just for someone you don't know yet. It's a good foot in the door, and I feel like I've spoken to a lot of people that maybe I otherwise would not have gotten access to.

I think one time, I'm just now remembering this, doing the guest mining like we're talking about, I would go on a couple of popular, top entrepreneur podcasts, and I would have a virtual assistant go through and contact people and just see who would respond. And one guy that responded was the author of the book No More Mr. Nice Guy. Have you heard of this book?

Bryan McAnulty:

I don't think I have.

Robert Plank:

Okay, but it's kind of self-explanatory and it's this huge bestseller and it's been on the charts for all kinds of years. And if it were me contacting, I would have skipped over him because there were all these people talking about their SaaS, their startup and VC funding, and then here's this No More Mr. Nice Guy in the mix. But then he responded and then he was on my show and he blew me away, and now I forever get to be associated with this guy.

And then I think because of the confidence of that, one time William Hung added me on Facebook. Do you know William Hung from American Idol? And I guess William Hung, his fame's really gone up and down, and he kind of started and stayed as a punchline, as a joke. His attitude is like, “I'll take what I can get.” He's like, “This is something that got me famous. I'll go with it.” And he joined a club called Toastmasters where you work on your public speaking, and I was also in Toastmasters, so we ended up with some similar friends. And I think he might have added me just on accident or just adding whoever.

And then because of the accidental No More Mr. Nice Guy, Dr. Robert Glover was a guest, this guy William Hung—I'm like, if that hadn't happened, here I am and, you know, he's not super famous, but everyone knows the name. And I'm like, would he really fit, especially on a marketing show? And I asked him and he said yes. And so it's just funny how sometimes one accident leads to the next, and then you can end up just being associated with people that you otherwise wouldn't be associated with. And who knows if things lead to stuff or not, but it's good to always be on this quest for greaterness.

Bryan McAnulty [22:19]:

Yeah, I agree. All right, I want to get into a quick lightning round now. So I'm looking for a quick take or a 10-second answer for these next few. Do you think a small podcast can still attract big guests?

Robert Plank [22:30]:

Yes, eventually, but that shouldn't be your goal.

Bryan McAnulty [22:32]:

What is one sentence that makes a guest more likely to say yes?

Robert Plank [22:37]:

“I'd like to seem like a smart person for knowing you, and I'll promote our episode forever.”

Bryan McAnulty [22:42]:

That's great. Who is the most underrated type of guest to invite on a podcast?

Robert Plank:

Someone with an interesting story.

Bryan McAnulty:

What is one podcasting growth hack that you think is overrated?

Robert Plank:

Re-releasing old episodes.

Bryan McAnulty:

All right, that's great. And on the show, I like to have a guest ask a question to the audience. So Robert, if you could ask our audience anything, whether it's something you're curious about or want to get people thinking about, what would that be?

Robert Plank [23:04]:

It would be, what are you afraid of? You have a list of things that are in your comfort zone, things that maybe you can do, and other things that are on the opposite side of fear. What is in that list? What are you afraid to do?

Bryan McAnulty [23:16]:

Great thing to think about. Robert, I really enjoyed talking with you today. Before we get going, where else can people find you online?

Robert Plank [23:20]:

The podcast with almost 1,600 episodes, including the man, the myth, the legend, Bryan McAnulty, is at marketeroftheday.com. And my business is called dfypodcast.com. If you have a podcast that you're thinking of starting or need taking over, my team manages podcasts, including the distribution. So dfypodcast.com, and the podcast is marketeroftheday.com.

Bryan McAnulty [23:45]:

All right, Robert. Thanks so much.

Robert Plank:

Namaste, as they say.

Bryan McAnulty [23:49]:

I'd like to take a moment to invite you to join our free community of over 5,000 creators at creatorclimb.com. If you enjoyed this episode and want to hear more, check out the Heights Platform YouTube channel every Tuesday at 9:00 a.m. US Central. To get notified when new episodes release, join our newsletter at thecreatorsadventure.com. Until then, keep learning, and I'll see you in the next episode.

View All Episodes of The Creator's Adventure

Subscribe and be the first to know about new episodes

    Spotify Apple Podcasts YouTube Facebook

    MOST POPULAR:


    RECENT EPISODES:


    Spotify Apple Podcasts YouTube Facebook


    About the Host

    Bryan McAnulty is the founder of Heights Platform: all-in-one online course creation software that allows creators to monetize their knowledge.

    His entrepreneurial journey began in 2009, when he founded Velora, a digital product design studio, developing products and websites used by millions worldwide. Stemming from an early obsession with Legos and graphic design programs, Bryan is a designer, developer, musician, and truly a creator at heart. With a passion for discovery, Bryan has traveled to more than 30 countries and 100+ cities meeting creators along the way.

    As the founder of Heights Platform, Bryan is in constant contact with creators from all over the world and has learned to recognize their unique needs and goals.

    Creating a business from scratch as a solopreneur is not an easy task, and it can feel quite lonely without appropriate support and mentorship.

    The show The Creator's Adventure was born to address this need: to build an online community of creative minds and assist new entrepreneurs with strategies to create a successful online business from their passions.

    View All Episodes of The Creator's Adventure